Replay Grade v0.1: my own grades

This page needs no script and no tool to read. Text source: own-grades-v0.1.md (md5 8f5553c0bcb5b7d047d812858f743000). The criteria: the page of Replay Grade, or as text.

Version 0.1 of the criteria, draft of 2026-11-13, revised on 2026-11-14 (the list of changes is the last section of replay-grade-v0.1.md). Read at 09:50Z, on 14 November: the README at that commit was fetched at that time, and the site pages are a local copy of the site at ebec56c. One grade per claim; the grade says what the page lets a reader replay, not whether the claim is true. The grade of each line is computed from its five columns, not written by hand.

Read from the README of the showcase repository at commit a6eb1da (line numbers are those of that file) and, for the site, from a local copy of the pages published by the site repository at commit ebec56c. Columns: cmd a complete command is on the page; pt a named point of reading; ex an expected result is written; net the network and its identifier are written (n/a when the claim reads no chain); src a source a reader can open.

1. The README, claim by claim

#LineClaimCommandcmdptexnetsrcGradeFlagTo reach the next grade
R0121, 51-56A contract can read the score on-chain with getScore(address)cast call ORACLE "getScore(address)(...)" TARGET --rpc-url RPCyesnoyesyesyesBname the block (--block N) instead of a date
R022155 incident write-ups read, 7 about who controls a contract, 2 flaggedpython3 scripts/prove.py (line 31)yesnoyesn/ayesBscript command with no commit named (rule of the page: the script carries its own addresses and endpoints)name the commit the output was produced at
R0323Command 1 needs no key, only public RPCs, and takes about ten secondspython3 scripts/prove.pyyesnoyesn/ayesBscript command with no commit named (rule of the page: the script carries its own addresses and endpoints); the printed run says 3 s, the text says about ten secondswrite one number, with the date of the run
R043563 + 39 + 13 + 13 + 14 + 9 + 9 + 16 targets on 8 oracles equal the Watchpython3 scripts/prove.pyyesnoyesnoyesBscript command with no commit named (rule of the page: the script carries its own addresses and endpoints)name the block of each oracle and the chain ID of each
R0536176 targets: six sub-scores, push date and methodology hash identical on the chain and in the Watchpython3 scripts/prove.pyyesnoyesnoyesBscript command with no commit named (rule of the page: the script carries its own addresses and endpoints)name the blocks, write the chain IDs
R0637Solana devnet: 26 accounts, scores and hash identical to the Watch'spython3 scripts/prove.pyyesnoyesyesyesBscript command with no commit named (rule of the page: the script carries its own addresses and endpoints)name the slot
R07388 EVM oracles: hash, target count and push date equal the CHANGELOGpython3 scripts/prove.pyyesnoyesnoyesBscript command with no commit named (rule of the page: the script carries its own addresses and endpoints)name the blocks, write the chain IDs
R0839getScore of the example contract is 80, 100, 75, 100, 80, 85python3 scripts/prove.pyyesnoyesyesyesBthe page says at line 56 that the fifth value moved to 40 on 27 October: no stale flag, the printed run is of an older state; script command with no commit named (rule of the page: the script carries its own addresses and endpoints)replace the printed run by a current one, with the block
R0942Authority Facts v0.1: 202 JSON twins of the site conformpython3 scripts/prove.pyyesnoyesn/ayesBscript command with no commit named (rule of the page: the script carries its own addresses and endpoints)name the commit and the site version read
R1046Oracle on Robinhood Chain testnet (chain ID 46630), target on Robinhood Chain mainnet (chain ID 4663), checked with eth_chainId on 13 November (10:59, in UTC)none written (method name only)nonoyesyesyesCa time of day (10:59 UTC) is not a named point for a read of the chain: the block is asked foradd cast chain-id --rpc-url RPC once for each network
R1156The fifth value was 80 on 22 October and changed with the push of 27 October, method 2026.10.4 (the history)nonenonoyesnoyesCthe other part of the claim of line 56 is R39cite the CHANGELOG entry and a cast call at a block before and after the push
R3956The fifth value of getScore is 40 now (read with the cast call of lines 51-54)cast call ORACLE "getScore(address)(...)" TARGET --rpc-url RPC (lines 51-54)yesnoyesyesyesBpart of the claim of line 56 that the command replays (rule of the page: a claim whose parts differ is two lines)name the block (--block N)
R1259A contract can score 100 and still carry the lowest trust status of watch/trust.jsonnonenonononoyesCadd the command that reads trust.json for one contract and the expected status
R1359None of the three commands reads the status yetnone (the commands are on the page)nonononoyesCadd a line that shows each command's output has no status field
R1461l1CappedComposite is 57 for the Uniswap v3 factory; it is in api/scores.json, not on the chainnonenonononoyesCthe other part of the claim of line 61 is R40add the curl of api/scores.json and the field to compare
R4061The composite of the Uniswap v3 factory on the chain is 85cast call ORACLE "getScore(address)(...)" TARGET --rpc-url RPC (lines 51-54)yesnoyesyesyesBpart of the claim of line 61 that the command replays (the sixth value)name the block (--block N)
R1563The strict gate is 46 lines and the simple gate is 18 linesnonenononon/ayesCadd wc -l for the two files, with the commit
R4163The simple gate checks neither the age of the push nor the number of keysnone (the file integrations/authority_facts_gate.py is named)nononon/ayesCadd the command line of the simple gate on a label older than 72 hours and the line it prints
R1666-73The strict gate refuses the label of the Uniswap v3 factory with keys to move not read, and you asked for them (exit code 1), run on 12 November (21:45, in UTC)python3 integrations/authority_facts_gate_strict.py LABEL_URL --max-age-hours 72 --strictyesyesyesyesyesAalready A
R1773The simple gate prints ok: Robinhood Chain 85 (strong), 48 h to react on the same label (exit code 0)described, not written with its argumentsnoyesyesyesyesCa named point and an expected result, but no commandwrite the command line
R4273Without --strict, the same command with only --max-age-hours 72 prints the last push is older than 72.0 hours (run on 12 November, at 21:45 in UTC)described, not written with its argumentsnoyesyesyesyesCa named point and an expected result, but no commandwrite the command line, with the label address
R1873The label was built on 22 October from a push of 19 October; the oracle was pushed again on 10 NovembernonenonononoyesCthe label is linked on the page (lines 66 and 88) and carries the push datecite the CHANGELOG entry and the label fields last_pushed
R1975The Solana devnet oracle program is upgradeable and its upgrade authority is a given accountcurl ... getAccountInfo ... | python3 -c ... (line 78)yesnoyesyesyesBread time given in the README (21:48 on 12 November, in UTC), no slotwrite the slot of the response
R2075That authority account is a plain account with no codenonenononononoDadd getAccountInfo on the authority account and the expected owner and size
R2175The same account is admin and updater in the registry of the program: one signature can push scores and replace the programnonenononononoDname the registry account and add the call that decodes it
R2275The devnet genesis hash is written, and the program does not exist on Solana mainnet-betanonenononononoDadd getGenesisHash and the getAccountInfo on mainnet-beta with the expected null
R2381The eight EVM oracles are not upgradeable; one plain key holds their admin and updater roles per chain (see docs/LIMITS.md, section "The oracle's own composite, by chain")nonenonononoyesCadd the cast call for the owner of one oracle, per chain
R2487202 contracts on 9 oracles (8 EVM testnets and Solana devnet)python3 scripts/prove.pyyesnoyesnoyesBscript command with no commit named (rule of the page: the script carries its own addresses and endpoints); the claim is about chains, so the network is asked forname the blocks, write the chain IDs
R2587Zcash is separate, 6 targets attested by on-chain commitmentsnonenononononoDlink the attestation and the command that reads it
R2687Each record names the network of its targets (see watch/API.md)nonenonononoyesCadd the curl of one scores/*.json file and the field to read
R2787The dashboard shows the money behind the contracts where one was read, and the delay before a change appliesnone (a link)nonononoyesCname a contract and give the value the page should show
R2888One contract's label says who can move it, how many keys, how long others have to reactnone (a link)nonononoyesCadd the curl of the JSON twin and the fields to read
R2989scripts/brief.py morpho-blue gives a one-page briefpython3 scripts/brief.py morpho-blueyesnonon/ayesBno output shownshow the first lines of the output
R4389An agent can use it through the local MCP servernonenononon/anoDlink the server file and give the command that starts it
R3089One Atom feed per protocolnonenononononoDlink one feed and say what its first entry should hold
R3189The pinned commit of the action is the last commit that changed itnonenoyesnon/ayesCthe commit named on the page is the subject of the claim, so also its point of reading (rule of the page); no commandadd git log -1 -- action.yml
R3297Submitted to Colosseum's Crypto World's Fair on 12 October 2026none (a link)nononon/ayesClink the submission page itself
R33102The dated transactions of the oracles do not depend on git (table in docs/HISTORY.md)nonenonononoyesCadd one cast tx and the expected block
R44102Every commit up to 6 October 2026 is a snapshot or carries a round timenonenononon/anoDa statement about the history of the repositoryadd git log with the dates of the first commits
R45102The Watch keeps a hash-chained event log since 10 October 2026none (the file is not linked in that sentence)nononononoDlink events.jsonl and say what its first line holds
R46102The Watch signs its manifests since 11 October 2026nonenononononoDlink one signed manifest and the command that checks the signature
R34102The methodology hash is tied to the scoring code for every push after 30 September 2026nonenononon/anoDin tension with the CHANGELOG of 13 November, which says none of the nine hashes can yet be recomputed from this repositorycite scripts/lib/methodology.py and which pushes it recomputes
R35118The signing key of the Watch is the same in watch/API.md, in scripts/audit_public.py and on the provenance pagepython3 scripts/audit_public.py (checks a run)yesnoyesn/ayesBscript command with no commit named (rule of the page: the script carries its own addresses and endpoints); the expected key is written at line 118show the line the script prints when the key matches
R3621A DeFi contract that can be upgraded or reconfigured has someone who can do itnonenononon/anoDa premise, nothing to replaynone: keep as a premise or cut
R3721, 97The score reads exposure, how much one compromise can do; it does not predict who gets hitnonenononon/anoDa statement of what the score meanscite the back-test line of command 1 (R02) next to it
R4721Live on testnets todaynonenononononoDlink the Watch page that lists the oracles and their networks
R3827The script reads the chain with its own code, separate from the Watch'snone (the file is named)nononon/ayesCadd the list of files each reader imports

Total: 47 claims graded: 1 at A, 15 at B, 18 at C, 13 at D.

Excluded as not being claims, 10 passages: the slogan in the banner (line 7), the badges (lines 10 to 18), the disclaimer "Not an audit, not investment advice" (line 21), the stated purpose "so a lending market, a DAO or a wallet does not have to trust anyone's website" (line 21), the "Does not prove" line of command 1 (line 43), the two lists of links (lines 93 and 95), the licence sentence (line 97), the licence table (lines 104 to 116) and the attribution sentence (line 116).

2. The pages of the site: the ceiling of each page

A page can only give the grade its elements allow, and the table does not grade each of its claims. The ceiling below is the best grade any claim on the page could reach with what the page holds, found by a script that looks for a command in a code block, a block parameter other than latest, a sentence naming what to read in the answer, a written chain ID and an outside link (noter_fiches.py). It is an upper bound: most claims of a page grade lower.

PageCeilingcmdnamed blockexpectedchain IDsource
/oracle/api/Byesnoyesnoyes
/oracle/backtest/Cnonononoyes
/oracle/changelog/Byesnoyesyesyes
/oracle/compare/Cnonoyesnoyes
/oracle/Byesnoyesnoyes
/oracle/methodology/Byesnoyesnoyes
/oracle/provenance/Byesnononoyes
/oracle/research/aave-levels/Byesyesnonoyes
/oracle/research/chains/arbitrum/Byesnononono
/oracle/research/chains/base/Byesyesyesnono
/oracle/research/chains/ethereum-l1/Byesyesyesnono
/oracle/research/chains/hyperliquid/Byesnononono
/oracle/research/chains/Dnonononono
/oracle/research/chains/robinhood-chain/Byesnoyesnono
/oracle/research/chains/solana/Byesnoyesnono
/oracle/research/chains/tempo/Byesyesyesnono
/oracle/research/chains/zcash/Byesnoyesnono
/oracle/research/Cnonononoyes
/oracle/research/lido-bnb-bridges/Byesnoyesnoyes
/oracle/roles/Byesyesyesnono
/oracle/security/Cnonononoyes
/oracle/verify/Byesnoyesnoyes
/oracle/watch/Cnonononoyes

The 152 research notes under /oracle/notes/: ceiling 85 at B, 66 at C, 1 at D.

3. The contract pages

The 202 contract pages (/oracle/p/) are graded one by one by the same script, for their one claim, the score of the contract, which the page lets a reader re-read: 176 at B, 26 at C. None reaches A, because none of them reads or writes its chain ID. The 176 at B hold a curl call and an expected result; 84 of them name the block of the build (and say honestly that a public node cannot replay it) and 92 use latest, and none writes a chain ID. The 26 at C are the Solana pages: they point to a method and hold no command. The script reads the quotes of the pages as " (the version of 13 November missed them).

4. Where the grade is lowest, and the cheapest fix

Back to the dashboard. Not an audit, not investment advice.